Riyaz

1 article

Glossary
TERM

Ati-komal

A microtonal inflection slightly lower than the regular komal version of a note. Ati-komal swaras appear in some raags — notably the komal Re of Bhairav and the komal Ga and Dha of Darbari Kanhra — where the standard komal pitch is bent further down for expressive effect. The exact pitch is not fixed but shaped by raag and gharana convention.

Practise Raag BhairavWith a tanpura tuned for it · live sur feedback · free
Short read

Ati-komal is one of those concepts that you will rarely see in a textbook chart but will hear in every great performance. The standard Hindustani note system recognises three positions for each note: shuddh (natural), komal (flat — one semitone below shuddh), and, for Ma alone, teevra (sharp). But what experienced musicians actually do — and what serious students slowly learn to hear — is that within these positions there is microtonal variation. Some komal notes are bent further down than others. These extra-low komal notes are called ati-komal.

The most famous examples live in Bhairav and Darbari Kanhra. In Bhairav, the komal Re is not just komal — it is ati-komal, sung noticeably below the equal-tempered minor second. A singer who renders Bhairav's Re at standard komal pitch produces something that sounds approximately right but lacks the raag's characteristic plaintive weight. The ati-komal Re, with its subtle downward bend, is what makes Bhairav sound like Bhairav.

Similarly, in Darbari Kanhra, the komal Ga and komal Dha are both ati-komal — the gravelly, brooding quality of the raag depends on these notes being noticeably below standard komal pitch, with a heavy andolan that emphasises their lowered position. Ustad Amir Khan's Darbari Ga was particularly low; Pandit Bhimsen Joshi's Bhairav Re carried its own distinct depth. Different lineages have different conventions about how far to bend each ati-komal note, and these subtle differences are part of what gives each gharana its characteristic sound.

The exact pitch of an ati-komal note is not fixed by any equation. It is shaped by raag tradition, gharana convention, and the individual musician's ear. There is no scientific formula; there is only the trained sensibility built up over years of careful listening and patient riyaz with the tanpura. The drone is the essential teacher here — by listening to its resonant overtones and trying to find the note that makes the tanpura speak most strongly, you train the ear to hear and the voice to produce ati-komal accurately.

For the modern student, particularly those trained initially with keyboards or equal-tempered tuners, ati-komal can be the most challenging concept to internalise. The piano gives you twelve fixed pitches per octave; Hindustani music demands microtonal sensitivity that no fixed-pitch instrument can teach. In short: ati-komal is what separates a scale from a raag. Anyone can play the notes of Bhairav; only a trained ear and trained voice can produce ati-komal Re with the gravity the raag demands.

Continue reading — the deep dive
Deep dive
Practise Raag BhairavWith a tanpura tuned for it · live sur feedback · free
Hold to switch tabs