Riyaz

1 article

Glossary
MUSICIAN

Pt. V.N. Bhatkhande

Musicologist who created the modern ten-thaat classification system and collected thousands of bandishes across gharanas. His scholarly work provided the theoretical foundation for modern Hindustani music education.

Practise Raag YamanWith a tanpura tuned for it · live sur feedback · free
Short read

Every student who learns that Yaman belongs to the Kalyan thaat, or that Bhairav heads its own thaat family, is working within a framework created by one man. Pandit Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande did not invent Hindustani music theory — but he organised it into a system that could be taught, debated, and built upon.

Born in 1860 in Bombay, Bhatkhande was trained as a lawyer but devoted his life to musicology. He travelled extensively across the subcontinent, visiting courts, temples, and the homes of ustads and pandits, collecting bandishes and documenting raag structures that had been transmitted orally for generations. At a time when gharanas guarded their repertoire jealously and written theory was fragmentary, Bhatkhande undertook the monumental task of creating a unified system.

His most enduring contribution is the ten-thaat classification: Bilawal, Khamaj, Kafi, Asavari, Bhairavi, Bhairav, Kalyan, Marwa, Purvi, and Todi. Each thaat defines a parent scale from which multiple raags are derived. The system is not perfect — some raags resist neat categorisation, and the relationship between a raag and its thaat can be debated endlessly — but it gave Hindustani music a common vocabulary that transcended the privacy of individual gharanas.

Bhatkhande also developed the Sargam notation system widely used in North India and Pakistan today, making it possible to write down compositions that had previously existed only in memory. His multi-volume Hindustani Sangeet Paddhati documented hundreds of raags with their aaroh, avroh, chalan, and characteristic phrases — an encyclopaedic effort that remains a reference work a century later.

His legacy is sometimes contentious. Purists argue that the thaat system oversimplifies the fluid reality of raag practice, and that written notation can never capture the subtlety of a living musical tradition. These criticisms have merit. But without Bhatkhande's systematisation, the teaching of Hindustani music outside the guru-shishya tradition would be far more difficult. For any student picking up a textbook or studying raag theory, Bhatkhande's fingerprints are on every page.

Continue reading — the deep dive
Deep dive
Practise Raag YamanWith a tanpura tuned for it · live sur feedback · free
Hold to switch tabs